Lv 4
Bill asked in Politics & GovernmentGovernment · 1 month ago

is it about time  the electoral college is given the boot it has nothing to do with democracy ?

16 Answers

  • 1 month ago

    Well another Liberal who knows nothing about how the Constitution works, typical of these people, it was put in place to give a Fair Vote for the smaller States who have fewer people. Maybe you young People should Read a Book so you get the facts not the Google story !

  • 1 month ago

    we need majorty rule get rid of this other bs

  • 1 month ago


  • 1 month ago

    No, it was created way back when for a good reason. We cant have the big cities making all of the political decisions for the rest of the country. Regardless if you like the outcome of an election or not, our system has served us well.

  • What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
  • 1 month ago

    NO... without it the top 5 states and top 7 cities would be the deciders who wins the potus seat.


    Popular elections compared to Electoral ;

    Just keep these numbers in mind:

    Example.. Just the County of Los Angeles Ca. has about, 10.16 million people,

    New York City has about 8.623 million based on the 2017 census..

    the whole state of N Dakota has, 755,176 in the same year,

    Montana had, 1.053 million.

    Here are some facts maybe you never read about or studied while in school:

    Electoral Vote : Progression of Vote, Citizen votes for delegate or representative, generally in accordance with their allegiances/party affiliation. Delegates convene and vote. Winner of that vote is elected for the position in question.

    Popular Vote: Citizens vote for their choice of official for the position being elected. Votes are counted. Majority of votes is elected to that position.

    Electoral: Bureaucracy, Requires formation of some form of committee, college, or council to vote after they've been elected. May also have government oversight organizations.

    Pop; Bureaucracy; Requires no formation of such groups, nor the election of such groups. May also have government oversight organization

    Electoral: Establishment of Voting Districts; Mandatory, regional delegates run for given district's delegate locations via their party or individually.

    Popular: Establishment of Voting Districts; Not Required

    Electoral; Gerrymandering; Present and created as a result of voting districts.

    Popular; Gerrymandering; Not created due to lack of need for voting districts.

    Electoral; Party Benefits Favors majority parties, as they can concentrate resources, change bureaucracy, establish and gerrymander voting districts.

    Popular; Party Benefits; Favors no party size in particular, though greatly improves potential for minority parties e.g., a third political party in the U.S.

    Electoral; Modern History; Does not allow higher populated areas (say, CA or NY) to take advantage of being able to always vote for the candidate, thereby under representing the other rural areas of the nation.

    Popular; Modern History; Harder to accomplish beyond geographically-close groups prior to modern transportation and communication. These hindrances are no longer in place for developed nations.

  • Jeff D
    Lv 7
    1 month ago

    No thanks.    

  • Foofa
    Lv 7
    1 month ago

    Sure, you get to tell every state that isn't California, Florida, Texas or New York that their participation in national elections is no longer relevant. Good luck with that as a lot of them have fairly lenient gun laws. 

  • 1 month ago

    It has everything to do with democracy!. It prevents tyranny of the majority. It ensures the minority is protected.  

  • 1 month ago

    That's the way many people think about Trump.

  • Anonymous
    1 month ago

    No. Stupid idea .......

Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.